You have tried to shock us. You've cussed, you've been in many pretty awful movies. If you are going to rip off the band aid of being a goody too shoes. RIP THE DAMN THING OFF.
Do a nude scene, show vulnerability, maybe a scene where you don't seem to be doing a "Rachel". Look, you're cute, we love you, but change it up or we're never buying a ticket to one of your movies again.
Love, your fans.